Review of Shitolian
-
justtttice
- Posts: 10
- Joined: 08 Jun 2023, 06:11
- Favorite Book: Mithra
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 9
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-justtttice.html
- Latest Review: Deadly Waters: The Vietnam Naval War And Its Aftermath by Randy Miller
Review of Shitolian
[Following is a volunteer review of "Shitolian" by O Persaud.]
Shitolian by O Persaud is a thought-provoking book that delves into society, history, and the human condition. The poet challenges norms and sheds light on societal constructs, using powerful imagery and metaphors. Black and white drinking fountains symbolize segregation, while diamonds represent love paid for with others' suffering, critiquing the exploitative diamond industry. The poem explores identity and racial history, reflecting on the struggles of marginalized communities, especially African Americans, providing a relevant and significant contribution to the ongoing dialogue on racial equality.
What stood out to me in the poem was its remarkable utilization of vivid imagery and metaphors to effectively convey its message. The poet skillfully addresses pressing societal issues, such as racial segregation, resource exploitation, and the quest for identity, infusing their verses with emotion and poetic brilliance, which deserves admiration. One particular verse that truly captivated me was, ''What we want we forget about, what we need and yet we still want more until something happens and it’s all gone and we realize we’ve had everything we ever needed all along.'' This verse seems to express the idea that we should cultivate a greater sense of appreciation and contentment with what we possess, acknowledging that it might be more than enough to lead a meaningful life.
The reason why I dislike this book is that, despite its evident passion and emotion, it possesses certain weaknesses that warrant critique. One prominent concern is its lack of clarity and coherence. While the book explores significant topics such as racial segregation, resource exploitation, and the struggle for identity, it falls short of establishing a clear and unified narrative that effectively interconnects these themes. As a reader, I find it challenging to fully engage with the content due to the disjointed and confusing presentation. Consequently, these shortcomings hinder my overall enjoyment and appreciation of the book.
I would recommend this book to individuals who enjoy thought-provoking and intellectually stimulating reads. Those interested in exploring significant societal themes, such as racial segregation, resource exploitation, and the struggle for identity, will find the book particularly engaging. It is also suitable for readers who appreciate a unique perspective on various aspects of existence and society. The book was exceptionally well-edited and error-free.
I gave the book a rating of 4 out of 5 stars because it is a thought-provoking piece that effectively tackles significant themes and offers a unique perspective on various aspects of society and existence. The book's ability to engage readers and provoke contemplation is commendable. However, I felt that some sections could have been more explicit in their connections, and a more focused approach to certain themes could have further heightened the overall impact of the book. Despite these minor shortcomings, the book remains a compelling and insightful read, deserving of a solid 4-star rating.
******
Shitolian
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
Shitolian by O Persaud is a thought-provoking book that delves into society, history, and the human condition. The poet challenges norms and sheds light on societal constructs, using powerful imagery and metaphors. Black and white drinking fountains symbolize segregation, while diamonds represent love paid for with others' suffering, critiquing the exploitative diamond industry. The poem explores identity and racial history, reflecting on the struggles of marginalized communities, especially African Americans, providing a relevant and significant contribution to the ongoing dialogue on racial equality.
What stood out to me in the poem was its remarkable utilization of vivid imagery and metaphors to effectively convey its message. The poet skillfully addresses pressing societal issues, such as racial segregation, resource exploitation, and the quest for identity, infusing their verses with emotion and poetic brilliance, which deserves admiration. One particular verse that truly captivated me was, ''What we want we forget about, what we need and yet we still want more until something happens and it’s all gone and we realize we’ve had everything we ever needed all along.'' This verse seems to express the idea that we should cultivate a greater sense of appreciation and contentment with what we possess, acknowledging that it might be more than enough to lead a meaningful life.
The reason why I dislike this book is that, despite its evident passion and emotion, it possesses certain weaknesses that warrant critique. One prominent concern is its lack of clarity and coherence. While the book explores significant topics such as racial segregation, resource exploitation, and the struggle for identity, it falls short of establishing a clear and unified narrative that effectively interconnects these themes. As a reader, I find it challenging to fully engage with the content due to the disjointed and confusing presentation. Consequently, these shortcomings hinder my overall enjoyment and appreciation of the book.
I would recommend this book to individuals who enjoy thought-provoking and intellectually stimulating reads. Those interested in exploring significant societal themes, such as racial segregation, resource exploitation, and the struggle for identity, will find the book particularly engaging. It is also suitable for readers who appreciate a unique perspective on various aspects of existence and society. The book was exceptionally well-edited and error-free.
I gave the book a rating of 4 out of 5 stars because it is a thought-provoking piece that effectively tackles significant themes and offers a unique perspective on various aspects of society and existence. The book's ability to engage readers and provoke contemplation is commendable. However, I felt that some sections could have been more explicit in their connections, and a more focused approach to certain themes could have further heightened the overall impact of the book. Despite these minor shortcomings, the book remains a compelling and insightful read, deserving of a solid 4-star rating.
******
Shitolian
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
