Review of Northern Umbrage

[Alex Noori]

[Following is a volunteer review of "Northern Umbrage" by Dennis Lorenz Ph.D..]

---

4 out of 5 stars

---

Share This Review

---

While the text introduces an intriguing premise for a sci-fi mystery novella, there are some aspects that could be criticized:

Clichéd Elements: The description uses some clichéd elements commonly found in sci-fi and mystery genres. Phrases like "small tourist town," "deadly conundrum," and "Do you have the courage?" are somewhat overused and may not capture the attention of readers seeking a fresh and innovative story.

Lack of Specifics: The text provides a general overview of the plot but lacks specific details that could make the story more engaging. What exactly is the nature of the teratogenic beast? How does the zealous woodsman contribute to the unfolding events? More concrete information about the characters and the central conflict would enhance the text.

Predictability: The notion of chemical pollutants altering genetic expression in a wolf is a familiar concept in science fiction. To stand out, the novella should introduce unique twists or elements that differentiate it from similar stories in the genre.

Vague Characterization: The introduction of Young Dr. Buc Bucannon is interesting, but the text doesn't provide enough information about his character. Readers might be more engaged if they knew more about his background, motivations, or personal challenges.

Unsubstantiated Claims: The phrase "will force the community and the country to rethink their priorities regarding environmental pollution" is a bold claim. The text should provide more context or evidence to support this assertion, or it may come across as an exaggerated promise.

Grammar and Redundancy: The sentence "Pollution is not the solution" is somewhat redundant and could be rephrased for better impact. Additionally, the repetition of the phrase "small tourist town" in the first and last paragraphs could be refined to avoid redundancy.

In summary, while the text presents an interesting concept, refining the language, adding specificity, and avoiding clichés could elevate the novella's appeal and make it more compelling for potential readers.

******
Northern Umbrage
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon