Review of These Sacred Lands
-
Surendra Devi
- Posts: 14
- Joined: 06 Mar 2024, 00:39
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 11
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-surendra-devi.html
- Latest Review: These Sacred Lands by James Harold Kelly
Review of These Sacred Lands
[Following is a volunteer review of "These Sacred Lands" by James Harold Kelly.]
4 out of 5 stars.
In "These Sacred Lands" by James Harold Kelly, set in the 1870s, the Great Sioux War escalates, testing the bond between Lakota warrior Shadow Hawk and U.S. cavalryman Joshua Mackenzie. Amidst the aftermath of the Civil War and the lure of gold rushes in Montana and the Dakota Territories, tensions rise as settlers encroach upon sacred Lakota lands. As Shadow Hawk grapples with his family's future, Mackenzie is surprised by his decisions. Through meticulous historical research and vivid storytelling, Kelly paints a poignant portrait of a tumultuous era, capturing the spiritual significance of the Black Hills and the struggles of both Native Americans and settlers. Against the backdrop of Manifest Destiny, the novel explores themes of friendship, identity, and the devastating consequences of cultural collision, leaving readers immersed in a gripping tale of courage and sacrifice. This book grabbed a 4-star rating because.
What sets this novel apart is its meticulous attention to historical detail and its ability to vividly bring the past to life. Drawing from both historical records and informed conjecture, Kelly paints a vivid portrait of the era, capturing the hopes, fears, and struggles of both Native Americans and settlers alike. From the aftermath of the Civil War to the gold rushes in Montana and the Dakota Territories, the author skillfully weaves together the threads of history to create a rich tapestry of the American frontier. At the heart of the story lies the relationship between Shadow Hawk and Mackenzie, two men from vastly different worlds bound together by fate and circumstance. As the Great Sioux War reaches its climax, their friendship is put to the ultimate test, forcing them to confront their own beliefs and allegiances. Kelly handles their evolving dynamic with sensitivity and nuance, allowing readers to empathize with both characters as they navigate the complexities of loyalty and identity.
Moreover, "These Sacred Lands" offers a thought-provoking exploration of the clash between cultures and the devastating consequences of Manifest Destiny. Through the eyes of the Lakota, readers gain insight into the profound spiritual significance of the Black Hills and the river region, which are portrayed not merely as territories to be conquered but as sacred lands imbued with cultural and spiritual significance. As tensions escalate between the Lakota and encroaching settlers, the novel powerfully conveys the mounting anger and despair of a people fighting to protect their way of life.
I deducted a single star due to occasional inconsistencies in character development. While Shadow Hawk and Joshua Mackenzie are both intriguing figures with complex backgrounds, there were moments when their motivations felt somewhat unclear or underexplored. While the novel excels in capturing the broader historical context and the clash of cultures during the Great Sioux War, a stronger focus on character development could have added depth and nuance to the narrative. Despite this minor criticism, "These Sacred Lands" remains a thought-provoking and engaging read that offers valuable insights into a pivotal moment in American history.
The editing of the book is very good as there aren’t any typos in it.
In conclusion, "These Sacred Lands" is a compelling and immersive read that offers a captivating glimpse into a pivotal moment in American history. This book is a must-read for historic lovers.
******
These Sacred Lands
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
4 out of 5 stars.
In "These Sacred Lands" by James Harold Kelly, set in the 1870s, the Great Sioux War escalates, testing the bond between Lakota warrior Shadow Hawk and U.S. cavalryman Joshua Mackenzie. Amidst the aftermath of the Civil War and the lure of gold rushes in Montana and the Dakota Territories, tensions rise as settlers encroach upon sacred Lakota lands. As Shadow Hawk grapples with his family's future, Mackenzie is surprised by his decisions. Through meticulous historical research and vivid storytelling, Kelly paints a poignant portrait of a tumultuous era, capturing the spiritual significance of the Black Hills and the struggles of both Native Americans and settlers. Against the backdrop of Manifest Destiny, the novel explores themes of friendship, identity, and the devastating consequences of cultural collision, leaving readers immersed in a gripping tale of courage and sacrifice. This book grabbed a 4-star rating because.
What sets this novel apart is its meticulous attention to historical detail and its ability to vividly bring the past to life. Drawing from both historical records and informed conjecture, Kelly paints a vivid portrait of the era, capturing the hopes, fears, and struggles of both Native Americans and settlers alike. From the aftermath of the Civil War to the gold rushes in Montana and the Dakota Territories, the author skillfully weaves together the threads of history to create a rich tapestry of the American frontier. At the heart of the story lies the relationship between Shadow Hawk and Mackenzie, two men from vastly different worlds bound together by fate and circumstance. As the Great Sioux War reaches its climax, their friendship is put to the ultimate test, forcing them to confront their own beliefs and allegiances. Kelly handles their evolving dynamic with sensitivity and nuance, allowing readers to empathize with both characters as they navigate the complexities of loyalty and identity.
Moreover, "These Sacred Lands" offers a thought-provoking exploration of the clash between cultures and the devastating consequences of Manifest Destiny. Through the eyes of the Lakota, readers gain insight into the profound spiritual significance of the Black Hills and the river region, which are portrayed not merely as territories to be conquered but as sacred lands imbued with cultural and spiritual significance. As tensions escalate between the Lakota and encroaching settlers, the novel powerfully conveys the mounting anger and despair of a people fighting to protect their way of life.
I deducted a single star due to occasional inconsistencies in character development. While Shadow Hawk and Joshua Mackenzie are both intriguing figures with complex backgrounds, there were moments when their motivations felt somewhat unclear or underexplored. While the novel excels in capturing the broader historical context and the clash of cultures during the Great Sioux War, a stronger focus on character development could have added depth and nuance to the narrative. Despite this minor criticism, "These Sacred Lands" remains a thought-provoking and engaging read that offers valuable insights into a pivotal moment in American history.
The editing of the book is very good as there aren’t any typos in it.
In conclusion, "These Sacred Lands" is a compelling and immersive read that offers a captivating glimpse into a pivotal moment in American history. This book is a must-read for historic lovers.
******
These Sacred Lands
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
Latest Review: These Sacred Lands by James Harold Kelly
