Review of Women of Fire and Snow
-
Tara Beh
- Posts: 12
- Joined: 21 Jan 2023, 14:45
- Currently Reading: Spare
- Bookshelf Size: 13
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-tara-beh.html
- Latest Review: The Contentment Dilemma by Marcus Hurst
Review of Women of Fire and Snow
[Following is a volunteer review of "Women of Fire and Snow" by Nati del Paso.]
In Women of Fire and Snow, Nati del Paso presents a collection of stories that blend psychology, mysticism, and magic realism to shed light on the struggles of Mexican women in the face of environmental and social justice issues. The book follows the lives of protagonists Antonia, Emiliana, Yessica, Ashly, Luz, Jaciel, and Ixchel, whose stories demonstrate perseverance in dangerous and exhausting environments.
Women of Fire and Snow explores racism, femicide, and prejudice against women of colour by sharing the stories of the main characters. Through their individual stories, the book sheds light on the systemic discrimination that Mexican women face in their daily lives. Their strife is demonstrated in both in their home country and abroad. The book also highlights the intersections of various issues, such as environmental justice, social justice, and the immigrant experience, that affect women of color.
On the positive side, the book has a great blend of stories. The author addresses issues that are not only prevalent for women in Mexican culture, but can be applied to many other backgrounds and genders. From the struggles of first-generation immigrants, to the challenges of being a woman in a patriarchal society, del Paso manages to weave together themes of family, culture, and respect that transcend cultural and geographic boundaries.
One issue with the book is that the plot moves too quickly at times. In under 250 pages, the author tells the story and struggles of seven women. This is no easy feat and certainly impressive, but I would have preferred it if del Paso took her time with each character to delve deeper into their internal monologues, their struggles, their obstacles and accomplishments. There is a fantastic opportunity to engage with the reader and open the discourse of racism, sexual assault, and femicide by sharing the struggle of each character in more depth. Another downside is that the format randomly changes from third to first person between two stories, then back again to third. That inconsistency was odd.
My rating for the book is 4 out of 5 stars. It has a few shortcomings, such as the length of each story, which do not warrant all 5 stars. However, it is a compelling read for anyone interested in social justice issues and the immigrant experience.
The book is not for the faint-hearted and it is not suitable for children due to the mature content. Readers should be warned that there is a very disturbing scene of sexual assault that may upset some readers. I would recommend Women of Fire and Snow to a mature audience that is keen to explore the world of mystic realism. The stories wonderfully connect the mystic world with the struggles of everyday living.
By exposing the harms of racism and prejudice and bringing them to light, Women of Fire and Snow contributes to ongoing efforts towards building a more inclusive and just world. The book serves as a tool to create awareness, educate, and engage in meaningful discussions to challenge the status quo and promote social change.
******
Women of Fire and Snow
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
In Women of Fire and Snow, Nati del Paso presents a collection of stories that blend psychology, mysticism, and magic realism to shed light on the struggles of Mexican women in the face of environmental and social justice issues. The book follows the lives of protagonists Antonia, Emiliana, Yessica, Ashly, Luz, Jaciel, and Ixchel, whose stories demonstrate perseverance in dangerous and exhausting environments.
Women of Fire and Snow explores racism, femicide, and prejudice against women of colour by sharing the stories of the main characters. Through their individual stories, the book sheds light on the systemic discrimination that Mexican women face in their daily lives. Their strife is demonstrated in both in their home country and abroad. The book also highlights the intersections of various issues, such as environmental justice, social justice, and the immigrant experience, that affect women of color.
On the positive side, the book has a great blend of stories. The author addresses issues that are not only prevalent for women in Mexican culture, but can be applied to many other backgrounds and genders. From the struggles of first-generation immigrants, to the challenges of being a woman in a patriarchal society, del Paso manages to weave together themes of family, culture, and respect that transcend cultural and geographic boundaries.
One issue with the book is that the plot moves too quickly at times. In under 250 pages, the author tells the story and struggles of seven women. This is no easy feat and certainly impressive, but I would have preferred it if del Paso took her time with each character to delve deeper into their internal monologues, their struggles, their obstacles and accomplishments. There is a fantastic opportunity to engage with the reader and open the discourse of racism, sexual assault, and femicide by sharing the struggle of each character in more depth. Another downside is that the format randomly changes from third to first person between two stories, then back again to third. That inconsistency was odd.
My rating for the book is 4 out of 5 stars. It has a few shortcomings, such as the length of each story, which do not warrant all 5 stars. However, it is a compelling read for anyone interested in social justice issues and the immigrant experience.
The book is not for the faint-hearted and it is not suitable for children due to the mature content. Readers should be warned that there is a very disturbing scene of sexual assault that may upset some readers. I would recommend Women of Fire and Snow to a mature audience that is keen to explore the world of mystic realism. The stories wonderfully connect the mystic world with the struggles of everyday living.
By exposing the harms of racism and prejudice and bringing them to light, Women of Fire and Snow contributes to ongoing efforts towards building a more inclusive and just world. The book serves as a tool to create awareness, educate, and engage in meaningful discussions to challenge the status quo and promote social change.
******
Women of Fire and Snow
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
Latest Review: The Contentment Dilemma by Marcus Hurst
