Should authors be prohibited from posting in BOTM forum?
Moderator: Official Reviewer Representatives
- Scott
- Site Admin
- Posts: 4068
- Joined: 31 Jul 2006, 23:00
- Currently Reading: The Unbound Soul
- Bookshelf Size: 340
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-scott.html
- Reading Device: B00JG8GOWU
- Publishing Contest Votes: 960
Should authors be prohibited from posting in BOTM forum?
Imagine the following two similar scenarios with a real life monthly book club--
Scenario One: Imagine you are part of a real life book club where you meet to talk about a book with a few other people each month at a local restaurant. Imagine one time you are chatting honestly about that month's book and then in the middle of the discussion find out unbeknownst to you that the author has been sitting at the table next you listening, when suddenly mid-discussion the author joins in the discussion and starts answering questions being discussed and potentially disagreeing with opinion or statements other members have made about the book (even if those statements were made by the person before they even knew the author was listening).
Scenario Two: Imagine again that you are part of a real life book club where you meet to talk about a book with a few other people each month at a local restaurant. But this time imagine your book club invites the author to participate each month, and one time the author agrees and attends, and the author is introduced at the beginning of the meeting, and you all participate together knowing upfront the author is there and participating.
I think we can all agree scenario one is bad and scenario two is good. In this case, we can see why some people think it is an honor and pleasure to have the author join in on the BOTM discussions (like scenario two) but others think it is inappropriate for an author to post in the BOTM forum (especially when other members didn't realize the author would be reading and replying to their posts)
Neither of the two scenarios will ever be a perfect analogy for our situation, since we are an online book club in which the discussion posts are posted publicly online in writing. However, to avoid scenario one, I think we either need to choose between the following:
(A) prohibiting authors from posting in the BOTM forum entirely
or
(B) allow authors to post in the BOTM forum and work under the assumption they will be (even if they choose not to), but make it very clear upfront to all members posting in the forum that the author has been invited to participate and will be reading and potentially replying to their posts.
or
(C) invite each author in advance and go with B if the author agrees to participate and wants to participate and go with A each month that author either doesn't respond in advance or that the author prefers to not participate.
I think C might be best. Imagine if JK Rowling asked to participate in a discussion of Harry Potter with us. Sure it would change the tone of the discussion and might cause some people to avoid being critical at least out of generic politeness, but it would open up an entirely different kind of discussion worth having, as long as we knew she was present and participating in advance.
"Non ignara mali miseris succurrere disco." Virgil, The Aeneid
- kandscreeley
- Special Discussion Leader
- Posts: 11686
- Joined: 31 Dec 2016, 20:31
- Currently Reading: The Door Within
- Bookshelf Size: 487
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-kandscreeley.html
- Latest Review: The Elf Revelation by Jordan David
—Neil Gaiman
- Nisha Ward
- Previous Member of the Month
- Posts: 2311
- Joined: 04 Feb 2019, 15:00
- Favorite Book: Binti Home
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 321
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-nisha-ward.html
- Latest Review: Fear Not, Dream Big, & Execute by Jeff Meyer
- Reading Device: B0794RHPZD
- CommMayo
- Previous Member of the Month
- Posts: 1648
- Joined: 22 Oct 2017, 14:19
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 80
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-commmayo.html
- Latest Review: Changed by Vicki Stiefel
- Reading Device: B00G2Y4WNY
- Chrystal Oaks
- Posts: 1701
- Joined: 09 Jan 2019, 15:27
- Favorite Book: The Favor
- Currently Reading: The Fourth Kinetic
- Bookshelf Size: 1194
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-chrystal-oaks.html
- Latest Review: E M P Honeymoon by Dorothy May Mercer
- Neil deGrasse Tyson
- Chrystal Oaks
- Posts: 1701
- Joined: 09 Jan 2019, 15:27
- Favorite Book: The Favor
- Currently Reading: The Fourth Kinetic
- Bookshelf Size: 1194
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-chrystal-oaks.html
- Latest Review: E M P Honeymoon by Dorothy May Mercer
Also, I think it needs to be understood that if the author chooses to participate, to avoid using all caps when replying. I can empathize with an author when expressing frustration to a reply, but no all-caps please.Chrystal Oaks wrote: ↑28 Jun 2019, 18:18 I vote for C. Like you stated, nobody likes to be surprised.
- Neil deGrasse Tyson
- Gravy
- Gravymaster of Bookshelves
- Posts: 39044
- Joined: 27 Aug 2014, 02:02
- Favorite Book: As many as there are stars in the sky
- Currently Reading: The Ghost Tree
- Bookshelf Size: 1027
I'd go with A unless authors' posts will be subject to the same rules as other members.
If not (and if anything like ...what has happened... happens again), there's a great chance members will stop participating in the BOTM.
What is grief, if not love persevering?
Grief is just love with no place to go.
- Gravy
- Gravymaster of Bookshelves
- Posts: 39044
- Joined: 27 Aug 2014, 02:02
- Favorite Book: As many as there are stars in the sky
- Currently Reading: The Ghost Tree
- Bookshelf Size: 1027
I completely agree. All caps is not okay in polite discussion.Chrystal Oaks wrote: ↑28 Jun 2019, 19:26Also, I think it needs to be understood that if the author chooses to participate, to avoid using all caps when replying. I can empathize with an author when expressing frustration to a reply, but no all-caps please.Chrystal Oaks wrote: ↑28 Jun 2019, 18:18 I vote for C. Like you stated, nobody likes to be surprised.
You can report a post if you feel it breaks site rules.
What is grief, if not love persevering?
Grief is just love with no place to go.
- gali
- Previous Member of the Month
- Posts: 53653
- Joined: 22 Oct 2013, 07:12
- Currently Reading: Pride and Prejudice in Space
- Bookshelf Size: 2288
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-gali.html
- Reading Device: B00I15SB16
- Publishing Contest Votes: 0
I agree! I voted for A as well a while ago.
Pronouns: She/Her
"In the case of good books, the point is not to see how many of them you can get through, but rather how many can get through to you." (Mortimer J. Adler)
- Chrystal Oaks
- Posts: 1701
- Joined: 09 Jan 2019, 15:27
- Favorite Book: The Favor
- Currently Reading: The Fourth Kinetic
- Bookshelf Size: 1194
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-chrystal-oaks.html
- Latest Review: E M P Honeymoon by Dorothy May Mercer
I will remember this. Thanks!Gravy wrote: ↑03 Jul 2019, 03:48I completely agree. All caps is not okay in polite discussion.Chrystal Oaks wrote: ↑28 Jun 2019, 19:26Also, I think it needs to be understood that if the author chooses to participate, to avoid using all caps when replying. I can empathize with an author when expressing frustration to a reply, but no all-caps please.Chrystal Oaks wrote: ↑28 Jun 2019, 18:18 I vote for C. Like you stated, nobody likes to be surprised.
You can report a post if you feel it breaks site rules.
- Neil deGrasse Tyson
-
- Posts: 286
- Joined: 24 Dec 2019, 11:46
- Currently Reading: Zona: The Forbidden Land
- Bookshelf Size: 29
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-anngladys.html
- Latest Review: Christ Without a Bride by Michael J. Ray
-
- Posts: 156
- Joined: 08 Jul 2020, 05:46
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 26
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-cyrus-michino.html
- Latest Review: The Fox by M. N. J. Butler