Review of From Infamy to Hope

[Mikespice Mike]

[Following is an official OnlineBookClub.org review of "From Infamy to Hope" by Stephen Lewis.]

---

4 out of 5 stars

---

Share This Review

---

"From Infamy to Hope" is a historical fiction novel that immerses the reader in the turbulent times of 17th-century Puritan Boston. The author, Stephen Lewis, is a true expert in the literature and history of this era, skillfully weaving together factual events and fictional characters to craft a compelling story of survival, courage, and redemption.

The novel's protagonist, Rachel Moore, is a young housemaid who endures the harsh laws and oppressive culture of Puritan society. Accused of fornication, she bears a black "W" on her gown as a mark of shame. Her child is also sold to the Pequot Indians by her alcoholic father. Driven to find her child and escape her dire fate, she disguises herself as a boy soldier and joins the colonial army in the war against the Pequots. Along this journey, she encounters two influential figures in the colony: Governor John Winthrop, a ruler with an iron fist who enforces strict religious orthodoxy, and Anne Hutchinson, a staunch advocate for religious freedom and tolerance who challenges his authority.

The novel delves deep into themes of identity, faith, and justice through Rachel's perspective and those of other characters. Rachel grapples with her self-worth and sense of belonging, facing discrimination and violence from both Puritans and Pequots. She also questions her religious beliefs when confronted with the hypocrisy and cruelty of Puritan leaders and the wisdom and compassion of some Pequot elders. Her friendship with Anne Hutchinson, a mentor and confidante, offers her hope and healing. Anne Hutchinson emerges as a courageous and charismatic woman who defies patriarchal norms and speaks her mind. She also extends sympathy and generosity to help Rachel and other outcasts in the colony.

The novel stands out with its meticulous research and rich detail, effectively immersing readers in the historical context and atmosphere of 17th-century New England. The author employs authentic language and dialogue to capture the voices and mindsets of the characters. Vivid descriptions depict scenes of war, torture, and execution that characterized this era, unflinchingly portraying the brutality and horror of the conflict between colonists and natives, as well as the internal strife among the Puritans. The novel also provides insights into the culture and customs of the Pequot tribe and their perspective on the war.

I would give the book a 4 out of 5 stars rating. It is a well-written and engaging novel that offers a realistic and nuanced portrayal of 17th-century Puritan society and the Pequot War. I appreciate how the author develops Rachel Moore's character, showcasing her growth and transformation throughout the story. Additionally, the incorporation of historical figures such as Anne Hutchinson and John Winthrop adds depth and personality to the narrative. I learned a great deal about this period in American history and the issues and conflicts that defined it.

However, the reason I did not rate the book 5 stars is because I found some parts of the novel to be overly graphic and disturbing for my taste. While I understand the author's intent to depict the harsh reality and violence of the war, some scenes were excessively gruesome and unsettling. Additionally, some of the dialogue felt too modern and anachronistic for the 17th-century setting. A greater emphasis on authentic language and expressions would have better suited the historical context.

In summary, "From Infamy to Hope" is a powerful and compelling novel that explores themes of identity, faith, and justice during a time of turmoil and oppression. It will undoubtedly appeal to fans of historical fiction and anyone interested in learning more about this captivating period in American history.

Remarkably, I did not encounter any grammatical errors in the book. Stephen Lewis, the author, demonstrates proficiency and professionalism in his writing, showcasing a strong command of the English language. His use of clear and concise sentences, proper punctuation and capitalization, and impeccable spelling and grammar are commendable. Moreover, he adheres to the rules and conventions of historical fiction writing, maintaining historical accuracy and consistency by using the past tense, avoiding modern slang and jargon, and preserving the authenticity of the era. The book appears to be well-edited and proofread, as I did not detect any mistakes or typos.

"In Infamy to Hope" is a gripping and poignant novel that seamlessly blends history and fiction to tell the story of a woman's quest for freedom and dignity during a period of oppression and violence. It challenges readers to reflect on their own views of religion, morality, and humanity, while celebrating the enduring power of hope, love, and resilience in the face of adversity. I highly recommend this novel to anyone who enjoys historical fiction or seeks to gain insight into this captivating period in American history.

******
From Infamy to Hope
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon

[Okewunmi Pelumi]

I love your review. Thanks for sharing it. I'll have to read this book.

[Cara Wilding]

[Following is an official OnlineBookClub.org review of "From Infamy to Hope" by Stephen Lewis.]

The novel's protagonist, Rachel Moore, is a young housemaid who endures the harsh laws and oppressive culture of Puritan society. Accused of fornication, she bears a black "W" on her gown as a mark of shame. Her child is also sold to the Pequot Indians by her alcoholic father. Driven to find her child and escape her dire fate, she disguises herself as a boy soldier and joins the colonial army in the war against the Pequots.

This was an absolutely exquisite review! I adore when a writer successfully combines history and fiction without sacrificing authenticity. The plot provides this character with more adversity than what seems fair! The author is clearly not shy about exploring a number of prevailing themes and has the ability to create some strong imagery. Your description was persuasive - I've added this to my 'want to read' bookshelf. Thanks so much for this comprehensive and well-written review!