Official Review: Not the Same Water by Karen Black

Please use this forum to discuss historical fiction books. Common definitions define historical fiction as novels written at least 25-50 years after the book's setting.
Forum rules
Authors and publishers are not able to post replies in the review topics.
Post Reply
User avatar
Kirsi_78
Posts: 819
Joined: 01 Mar 2020, 12:01
2021 Reading Goal: 30
Currently Reading: My Living Will
Bookshelf Size: 50
Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-kirsi-78.html
Latest Review: The Legacy of Job's Wife by Cynthia Koelker

Official Review: Not the Same Water by Karen Black

Post by Kirsi_78 »

[Following is an official OnlineBookClub.org review of "Not the Same Water" by Karen Black.]
Book Cover
3 out of 4 stars
Share This Review


Becky is a young seamstress student from Red Wing, Minnesota. Together with her best friends, she signs up for an exciting day cruise on Lake Pepin – a daring thing to do without a male escort in the year 1890. The delightful adventure turns into a horrifying nightmare as a sudden storm sinks the Sea Wing and the majority of the passengers drown in the raging waters. Becky survives barely, with the help of Army Lt. Bill Cravats. The destiny bounds Becky and Bill together in the aftermath of the Sea Wing disaster, and the two fall in love. Their blossoming relationship is interrupted when Bill gets reassigned to the 7th Cavalry in Pine Ridge, South Dakota, where Indians are said to be causing trouble. Becky is forced to stay behind and decides to follow her dream of becoming a doctor. A woman as a medic was almost unheard of, but against all odds, Becky gets accepted to medical school.

Together with the 7th Cavalry, Army Lt. Bill Cravats faces some horrific confrontations with the Indians in South Dakota. Becky’s dearly beloved fiancée is reported missing in action, and the two lovers lose track of each other. It seems that Bill Cravats is dead, but his fellow soldiers never manage to find his body. Becky is heartbroken when she receives the news. She now commits all her energy to her medical career and to the dream of becoming a trauma surgeon. Unfortunately, her womanhood stands in the way, and no major hospital will admit her into their trauma surgeon intern and residency program. She commits some unimaginable deeds to reach her goal. Is she going to make her dream come true? Is she ever going to find true love again?

Not the Same Water by Karen Black is a historical romance novel consisting of five different parts, which are bound to well-known historical incidents. The author has created a set of imaginary characters placing their stories inside of past real-life events. The mixture of reality and make-believe is intriguing, as I enjoyed learning about the historical background. It was fascinating to imagine how the world looked like in those days when there were no cell phones or internet available, and women could not do what they wanted. Instead of making a career, they were supposed to dedicate their lives to finding an appropriate man to marry and raise a family. The descriptions of women's clothing were utterly fascinating, and learning about the traces of unwritten social rules felt rather incredible.

The author’s style of writing was absorbing. It made me feel like located right in the middle of the events instead of just flipping through the pages of another book. The story was smooth and entertaining but also very predictable. Much to the author’s misfortune, I have read at least a dozen romance novels with almost identical plot development. Therefore, I was able to guess how the story would unfold. Until the very end, I was hoping for some element of total surprise to occur, but to my vast disappointment, all my conjectures hit the target with a sharpshooter's accuracy. Besides, there was one detail that kept on disturbing me. The story was somewhat jumping back and forth in time, and even though the dates were marked at the beginning of every chapter, I found myself checking and re-checking until the verge of frustration. I couldn’t help but wonder if there had been another less-disturbing structural solution available.

Not the Same Water is more than a suitable companion for some sunny Sunday afternoon daydreaming, and hence, I warmly recommend it to all adult fans of historical romance. The book has some slightly erotic scenes included, as romance novels often tend to have. Consequently, I do not feel comfortable recommending it to the minors.

As mentioned above, the reading experience was entertaining. Even so, this was not the best book I have ever read. Editing was on a satisfactory level, as I did not encounter more than a few typing mistakes and other small mishaps. The thing is, I feel that one of the most significant features of a good book is the element of surprise. Unfortunately, this is where Not the Same Water by Karen Black failed to fill my expectations. Therefore I am willing to rate this book with 3 out of 4 stars. However, Karen Black has managed to create a believable picture of the times. Therefore, I want to congratulate the author for offering an intriguing glimpse into the life of times before modern technology.

******
Not the Same Water
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
User avatar
Miriam Molina
Previous Member of the Month
Posts: 9602
Joined: 02 May 2017, 20:17
Favorite Book:
Currently Reading: A Stained White Radiance
Bookshelf Size: 643
Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-miriam-molina.html
Latest Review: Posing for Rodin by Charles McGrail
Reading Device: B00KC6I06S

Post by Miriam Molina »

Too bad the plot was too predictable. But learning history via interesting stories is fun for me, so I am open to treading these waters.
User avatar
SamaylaM
Posts: 926
Joined: 11 Aug 2020, 04:43
Currently Reading: Gilded Lily
Bookshelf Size: 75
Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-samaylam.html
Latest Review: The Shoeshine Boy by Walter Reinhard & Maurice Kleckin

Post by SamaylaM »

I like reading historical novels and being transported to a time when things were so different. Sounds like a good read minus the lack of the element of surprise. Thank you for such a comprehensive and beautiful review!
User avatar
Raluca_Mihaila
Posts: 2355
Joined: 03 Aug 2020, 14:52
2021 Reading Goal: 60
Favorite Book: The Brothers Karamazov
Currently Reading:
Bookshelf Size: 149
Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-raluca-mihaila.html
Latest Review: Entanglement - Quantum and Otherwise by John K Danenbarger

Post by Raluca_Mihaila »

Sometimes I like an easy read, although everything is predictable and sentimental. So thank you for your recommendation and congratulations for the interesting review!
User avatar
Nmesoma
Posts: 247
Joined: 24 May 2018, 10:45
Currently Reading:
Bookshelf Size: 46
Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-nmesoma.html
Latest Review: The Biblical Clock by Daniel Friedmann and Dania Sheldon

Post by Nmesoma »

I love historical romance reads, and gosh, a story with reality and fiction inter-woven, yes please! Happy for the review and recommendation.
User avatar
Kirsi_78
Posts: 819
Joined: 01 Mar 2020, 12:01
2021 Reading Goal: 30
Currently Reading: My Living Will
Bookshelf Size: 50
Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-kirsi-78.html
Latest Review: The Legacy of Job's Wife by Cynthia Koelker

Post by Kirsi_78 »

Miriam Molina wrote: 22 Nov 2020, 02:42 Too bad the plot was too predictable. But learning history via interesting stories is fun for me, so I am open to treading these waters.
Learning history was definitely one of the best parts of this book. Thanks for commenting!
User avatar
sanjus
Posts: 2378
Joined: 08 May 2018, 12:47
2021 Reading Goal: 21
Currently Reading: Charles' Story
Bookshelf Size: 401
Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-sanjus.html
Latest Review: Say Their Name by Wanda Weathersby
Reading Device: B00I15SB16

Post by sanjus »

A woman going alone without a male escort on a ship in 1890's is quite insprational. Thanks for detailed honest review.
life is only knowing the unknown, we can do this by reading books easily- Online book club is a great place for this. This is what I believe.
User avatar
anua24060
Posts: 481
Joined: 07 May 2020, 09:05
Currently Reading:
Bookshelf Size: 57
Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-anua24060.html
Latest Review: Twisted But True by Darren Burch

Post by anua24060 »

This seems like a good historical novel. The heroine seems like a strong woman who wants to achieve her dreams. It's worth a read. Thanks for the great review!
Manali_DC
Posts: 448
Joined: 05 Jun 2017, 00:51
Currently Reading: A Little Life
Bookshelf Size: 73
Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-manali-dc.html
Latest Review: Flat Top Mountain Ranch -- the beginning by James E Doucette

Post by Manali_DC »

I like Historical fiction and Becky sounds like a gutsy heroine who dares to do things unconventional for her time! Great review.
User avatar
Kirsi_78
Posts: 819
Joined: 01 Mar 2020, 12:01
2021 Reading Goal: 30
Currently Reading: My Living Will
Bookshelf Size: 50
Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-kirsi-78.html
Latest Review: The Legacy of Job's Wife by Cynthia Koelker

Post by Kirsi_78 »

SamaylaM wrote: 22 Nov 2020, 03:11 I like reading historical novels and being transported to a time when things were so different. Sounds like a good read minus the lack of the element of surprise. Thank you for such a comprehensive and beautiful review!
That is indeed cool, being able to take a glimpse to a different time! Thanks for your kind words :tiphat:
User avatar
Kirsi_78
Posts: 819
Joined: 01 Mar 2020, 12:01
2021 Reading Goal: 30
Currently Reading: My Living Will
Bookshelf Size: 50
Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-kirsi-78.html
Latest Review: The Legacy of Job's Wife by Cynthia Koelker

Post by Kirsi_78 »

raluca_mihaila wrote: 22 Nov 2020, 04:42 Sometimes I like an easy read, although everything is predictable and sentimental. So thank you for your recommendation and congratulations for the interesting review!
Thanks for stopping by and commenting! Easy reads can be really entertaining.
User avatar
Kirsi_78
Posts: 819
Joined: 01 Mar 2020, 12:01
2021 Reading Goal: 30
Currently Reading: My Living Will
Bookshelf Size: 50
Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-kirsi-78.html
Latest Review: The Legacy of Job's Wife by Cynthia Koelker

Post by Kirsi_78 »

Nmesoma wrote: 22 Nov 2020, 06:12 I love historical romance reads, and gosh, a story with reality and fiction inter-woven, yes please! Happy for the review and recommendation.
Reality mixed with fiction often works better than completely made-up story, and in this case it worked perfectly! Thanks for commenting!
User avatar
Kirsi_78
Posts: 819
Joined: 01 Mar 2020, 12:01
2021 Reading Goal: 30
Currently Reading: My Living Will
Bookshelf Size: 50
Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-kirsi-78.html
Latest Review: The Legacy of Job's Wife by Cynthia Koelker

Post by Kirsi_78 »

sanjus wrote: 22 Nov 2020, 21:53 A woman going alone without a male escort on a ship in 1890's is quite insprational. Thanks for detailed honest review.
It is hard to imagine how it has been back then, as nowadays everything is so very different :D thanks for stopping by and commenting!
User avatar
Kirsi_78
Posts: 819
Joined: 01 Mar 2020, 12:01
2021 Reading Goal: 30
Currently Reading: My Living Will
Bookshelf Size: 50
Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-kirsi-78.html
Latest Review: The Legacy of Job's Wife by Cynthia Koelker

Post by Kirsi_78 »

anua24060 wrote: 22 Nov 2020, 23:34 This seems like a good historical novel. The heroine seems like a strong woman who wants to achieve her dreams. It's worth a read. Thanks for the great review!
She was indeed a strong woman with extraordinary set of skills. Thanks for your kind words!
User avatar
Kirsi_78
Posts: 819
Joined: 01 Mar 2020, 12:01
2021 Reading Goal: 30
Currently Reading: My Living Will
Bookshelf Size: 50
Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-kirsi-78.html
Latest Review: The Legacy of Job's Wife by Cynthia Koelker

Post by Kirsi_78 »

Manali_DC wrote: 23 Nov 2020, 01:20 I like Historical fiction and Becky sounds like a gutsy heroine who dares to do things unconventional for her time! Great review.
Thanks for stopping by and commenting!
Post Reply

Return to “Historical Fiction”