Official Review: The Ordinary Extraordinary Dog

[gen_g]

It's such a pity about the lack of editing in what would have otherwise been a good book. Thanks for the review, Bianka! (:

[Bianka Walter]

It's disappointing that a four-star potential ends up with one star. I absolutely loved the premise - and title. I agree that children enjoy ideas that are somewhat illogical. The author needs to put his best foot (or book version) forward! Thanks for the entertaining review!

I hope he does! Thanks for the comments, Cotwani

[Bianka Walter]

I always think that the .pdf books must be pre-publication versions. Hopefully the author irons out the problems with this because it sounds like a premise that children would love. I want to see the picture of the dog eating Cornflakes!

It's very cute Especially because the author draws his eyes so big. And you know - big eyes = cuteness overload.
Thanks for the comments!

[Bianka Walter]

It sounds like such a cute premise, but a kid's book especially needs to get the editing right.

That's exactly why I said that I couldn't recommend it. I hope he sorts it out.
Thanks for stopping by

[Bianka Walter]

Lewin eats cornflakes for breakfast? What an odd dog. I agree that children would be interested in the silliness of this tale. Too bad you didn't find it worth recommending.

Can you imagine a dog sitting at a table eating cornflakes? What fun for kids!

[Bianka Walter]

It's such a pity about the lack of editing in what would have otherwise been a good book. Thanks for the review, Bianka! (:

It is a pity! But easy to sort out
I hope he does.
Thanks, Gen!

[FictionLover]

I always think that the .pdf books must be pre-publication versions. Hopefully the author irons out the problems with this because it sounds like a premise that children would love. I want to see the picture of the dog eating Cornflakes!

It's very cute Especially because the author draws his eyes so big. And you know - big eyes = cuteness overload.
Thanks for the comments!

Yes, we all love huge puppy-dog or kitten eyes.



(Or frog eyes!)

[revna01]

I think the author has a pleasant idea here, but needs to see through some of the obvious deficits before it's reader-ready. Thanks for a wonderful review

[Debjani Ghosh]

The author seems to have failed to cash in on the brilliant premise. I would have loved to read this book solely due to the protagonist being a dog but now, I think I will wait till the author brings in a polished feel to the book. Thanks for the review.

[Book Lover 35]

That's a shame about the editing. The book sounds like it could have a lot of potential. Thank you for the review!

[Manang Muyang]

It is funny why reviews of one-star books get a lot of replies. What could have made the book so unattractive? I do feel for the devastated authors, but what is a reviewer to do?

I like your diplomacy in the review, Bianka! I hope the dog owner takes it like a dog, oops, like a man.

[Bianka Walter]

I think the author has a pleasant idea here, but needs to see through some of the obvious deficits before it's reader-ready. Thanks for a wonderful review

Thank you for reading it! It is definitely a nice idea - I hope he smoothes it over

[Bianka Walter]

The author seems to have failed to cash in on the brilliant premise. I would have loved to read this book solely due to the protagonist being a dog but now, I think I will wait till the author brings in a polished feel to the book. Thanks for the review.

I look forward to the polished version too!
Thank you for stopping by

[Bianka Walter]

That's a shame about the editing. The book sounds like it could have a lot of potential. Thank you for the review!

It will be a great book once it's been edited for sure!
Thanks for popping past

[Bianka Walter]

It is funny why reviews of one-star books get a lot of replies. What could have made the book so unattractive? I do feel for the devastated authors, but what is a reviewer to do?

I like your diplomacy in the review, Bianka! I hope the dog owner takes it like a dog, oops, like a man.

I really struggled with this rating. I actually decided that one star (in this case) was better than two because people WOULD read the review because of the low rating and see that the book was actually very salvageable. Well, I hope so anyway. And I hope I see a new review of this book soon with 4 happy stars