Official Review: Jamie Collins' Mystical Adventures: RING...

[Jackie Holycross]

I am intrigued that the plot happens all in one day. Interesting.

[Christina Rose]

I am intrigued that the plot happens all in one day. Interesting.

It’s definitely a pretty busy day

[María Andrea Fernández Sepúlveda]

Part of what I love and appreciate so much about this novel, is also what I think the latter part of the intended audience may find a bit constricting. Our middle-schoolers are already being exposed to epic battle scenes, and are experiencing the loss of beloved characters. The sheer positivity, and the almost gentle security, of this book may not be enough to hold their interests. On the other hand, this makes it ideal for the younger portion of the target age group. These budding fantasy readers can enjoy the incredible descriptions of fantastic worlds and mystical creatures without having to deal with the darker elements of this genre. Parents can rest assured that their child's imagination is being nourished while his or her innocence stays intact.

The fact that you're able to give us a parents perspective is invaluable. Many of us can read the book, but we're not so in touch with what kids like or dislike. I think you're right: older kids expect much more action-packed and violent scenes, but I believe "innocent" books like this one have their place and are very valuable.
Great review, thanks!