Question about Editorial Analysis section of Reviewer Score

[Anirudh Badri]

Hello all.

I am a new reviewer and my first review is currently pending, and as a result there is no editorial data yet.

On the scores page, it mentions that in the absence of the editorial data "Book of the month participation used instead."

The questions regarding scores on that page further mention that "if no editorial analysis data, total number of book of the month posts used instead". I have participated in the Book of the Month discussions and that is reflected in the column dedicated to that participation. However, the score for Editorial analysis still remains 0.

Could someone please clarify why this is happening, or if there is a mistake, please address it. Thank you.

[stoppoppingtheP]

I think that the Editorial Analysis score goes from -30 to +30 points. Thus if you have 0 points, you are in the middle and have to work your way up with positive review ratings. At least that's how I think it works.