Review of Quanta in Distress

[Do Thi Huong]

[Following is an official OnlineBookClub.org review of "Quanta in Distress" by Sadri Hassani.]

---

5 out of 5 stars

---

Share This Review

---

Quanta in Distress is physicist Sadri Hassani’s scientific book that aims to debunk misconceptions about the relationship between quantum physics and New Age spirituality.

Quantum healing has become a buzzword in the New Age movement. According to the book, pop-spiritualist teachers have exploited the theory of quantum mechanics to support their spiritual beliefs and practices, such as yoga, meditation, and Ayurveda. One such example is the work of Deepak Chopra, which is carefully examined in this book.

The book is well-researched, with the author tracing the origins of quantum physics back to its early days. He discusses how its founders sometimes mystified the subject by infusing their personal philosophical beliefs into their scientific work. The probabilistic nature of quantum physics, which challenges the determinacy of classical physics, combined with the influx of Eastern theosophy into Western philosophy, has paved the way for spiritualists to misuse quantum physics. These factors are explored through in-depth analysis, guiding readers from the foundational principles of particle physics to the laws of probability, supported by cited resources.

The book might be controversial for spiritualists who believe in Eastern practices. The author strongly opposes alternative medicines such as Ayurveda and acupuncture, which are not scientifically proven methods. Nevertheless, these practices have been part of Eastern traditional medicine and culture for millennia.

Religious readers might also find some ideas in the book contrary to their beliefs. For example, the claim that "We live by the rules of chance.” (page 79), as explained by the rule of probability, does not sound right in Buddhist teachings where every event has a cause and effect. However, the bottom line is that science and spirituality are separate domains that offer different perspectives. Both can coexist without conflict unless one tries to merge them, like “New Agers who want to mix the message and the messenger”—the science and the scientist’s personal conviction.

Despite the controversial nature of this argument, the book does not disrespect religions. The author stays within the realm of science, focusing on exposing the appropriation of quantum physics by New Age gurus. The discussion is extensive, well-supported, and written with clear scientific explanations. It is grounded in the principles of physics and accessible to those who want to develop critical thinking in their spiritual practices.

All things considered, I find no reason to rate Quanta in Distress less than 5 out of 5 stars.

******
Quanta in Distress
View: on Bookshelves

[Joe Alex 2]

As someone who values both science and open-mindedness, I am curious about how Sadri Hassani explains the misuse of quantum mechanics without disrespecting cultural or spiritual traditions. Even though I haven’t read this book before, I can tell from your review that this book would be an interesting and thought-provoking read because everything catches my interest, especially the argument between probability and determinism, as it challenges some deeply held beliefs. 

[patricia MGBEMENA]

I would want to understand what is meant by pop-spiritualist teachers exploiting quantum mechanicsa and what interests me most in the book is the yoga, meditation, and Ayurveda discussed.