Review by Kansas City Teacher -- From Liberty to Magnoli...
3 posts
[Following is a volunteer review of "From Liberty to Magnolia: In Search of the American Dream" by Janice S. Ellis.]
[rbc=4]id260560-125[/rbc]
I selected this book because I am drawn to inspirational stories, and also because much of the author’s story takes place in my own city - Kansas City, Missouri. I was not disappointed. First, this story of emotional endurance is truly remarkable. Many have not experienced the effects of prejudice, or suffered at the hands of an abusive spouse. Through her powerful words, Dr. Ellis gives readers an intimate account of her arduous journey from farmhouse to penthouse. Secondly, the writing style is captivating. Detailed descriptions, rich vocabulary, and reflection create compelling arguments for her opinions. I found myself tearing up at some events in her early life, and I felt the sting of racism in a way I have not felt while reading similar accounts in other books. I cringed at the hurtful words that were spoken by her teacher. I smiled and sighed at the acts of kindness of strangers, college professors, and commentators. I felt content and hopeful at the sense of community during a time when they needed each other most.
This memoir is one of the most inspirational writings I have ever read. I admire the author. I am even more impressed with the depiction of her mother. Many themes are at play in this book, and among the strongest is the bond of family. Psychological studies across cultures indicate the strongest predictor in success is attunement with the same-sex parent during the formative years in early childhood. The relationship Dr. Ellis had with her mother is no doubt a powerful force that helped propel her to success and independence in spite of the many formidable obstacles in her life.
What I liked best about the book is the introspection the author uses. Since she was a young child, Dr. Ellis has been a thinker. I love how she gives specific examples of the events that have influenced her. An unlikely phobia. Thoughtless words from a teacher. Blatant racism and discrimination. Not only does she detail how negative events have influenced her, but she gives credit to the many people who have influenced her positively. The phobia creates opportunities that open many doors to a career in writing. Hurtful words spark a fire to initiate change. A compassionate police officer really listens. I could feel the connection she had with her mother, and the beautiful words from the pages of this book would make any mother proud. I also appreciated the metaphors and analogies the author used. The use of these literary devices allows the reader to be truly connected to the story. Even the title becomes a beautiful metaphor during the book.
The only negative comment I can make about this book is that there was a rather lengthy section about the writings and philosophies of her mentors in the middle part of the story. To me, it seemed like an interruption to the emotional flow of the book. However, the inclusion of commentary on political issues could be interesting for some readers, making this book appeal to a wider audience.
This book is not only for women or those interested in the Civil Rights Movement. This is a story of humanity, history, and relationships. I gladly rate this book 4 out of 4 stars. I recommend this memoir for all readers, regardless of their experiences or backgrounds. There were a few very minor sexual references, but I do not feel that this would be offensive for any reader. There were only a few instances of minor profanity. The book seemed professionally edited. I did find a few errors in grammar, but these errors did not take away from the message of this profound writing. I am glad this story was told, and I have the utmost respect for the author.
******
From Liberty to Magnolia: In Search of the American Dream
View: on Bookshelves |
I selected this book because I am drawn to inspirational stories, and also because much of the author’s story takes place in my own city - Kansas City, Missouri. I was not disappointed. First, this story of emotional endurance is truly remarkable. Many have not experienced the effects of prejudice, or suffered at the hands of an abusive spouse. Through her powerful words, Dr. Ellis gives readers an intimate account of her arduous journey from farmhouse to penthouse. Secondly, the writing style is captivating. Detailed descriptions, rich vocabulary, and reflection create compelling arguments for her opinions. I found myself tearing up at some events in her early life, and I felt the sting of racism in a way I have not felt while reading similar accounts in other books. I cringed at the hurtful words that were spoken by her teacher. I smiled and sighed at the acts of kindness of strangers, college professors, and commentators. I felt content and hopeful at the sense of community during a time when they needed each other most.
This memoir is one of the most inspirational writings I have ever read. I admire the author. I am even more impressed with the depiction of her mother. Many themes are at play in this book, and among the strongest is the bond of family. Psychological studies across cultures indicate the strongest predictor in success is attunement with the same-sex parent during the formative years in early childhood. The relationship Dr. Ellis had with her mother is no doubt a powerful force that helped propel her to success and independence in spite of the many formidable obstacles in her life.
What I liked best about the book is the introspection the author uses. Since she was a young child, Dr. Ellis has been a thinker. I love how she gives specific examples of the events that have influenced her. An unlikely phobia. Thoughtless words from a teacher. Blatant racism and discrimination. Not only does she detail how negative events have influenced her, but she gives credit to the many people who have influenced her positively. The phobia creates opportunities that open many doors to a career in writing. Hurtful words spark a fire to initiate change. A compassionate police officer really listens. I could feel the connection she had with her mother, and the beautiful words from the pages of this book would make any mother proud. I also appreciated the metaphors and analogies the author used. The use of these literary devices allows the reader to be truly connected to the story. Even the title becomes a beautiful metaphor during the book.
The only negative comment I can make about this book is that there was a rather lengthy section about the writings and philosophies of her mentors in the middle part of the story. To me, it seemed like an interruption to the emotional flow of the book. However, the inclusion of commentary on political issues could be interesting for some readers, making this book appeal to a wider audience.
This book is not only for women or those interested in the Civil Rights Movement. This is a story of humanity, history, and relationships. I gladly rate this book 4 out of 4 stars. I recommend this memoir for all readers, regardless of their experiences or backgrounds. There were a few very minor sexual references, but I do not feel that this would be offensive for any reader. There were only a few instances of minor profanity. The book seemed professionally edited. I did find a few errors in grammar, but these errors did not take away from the message of this profound writing. I am glad this story was told, and I have the utmost respect for the author.
******
From Liberty to Magnolia: In Search of the American Dream
View: on Bookshelves |
You are not logged in. Please log in or sign up to view members replies, participate in the discussion, and access more features.
