Official Review: Judgment At Hickory Nut Gorge

Please use this sub-forum to discuss any crime, thriller, mystery or horror books or series.
Forum rules
Authors and publishers are not able to post replies in the review topics.
Post Reply
User avatar
Previous Member of the Month
Posts: 1452
Joined: 07 Jan 2018, 03:51
Favorite Book: The Magic Mountain
Currently Reading:
Bookshelf Size: 456
Reviewer Page:
Latest Review: Noonday Flower by Carla C. Ohse
Reading Device: B00JG8GOWU

Official Review: Judgment At Hickory Nut Gorge

Post by cristinaro »

[Following is an official review of "Judgment At Hickory Nut Gorge" by Dan Hedgepath.]
Book Cover
2 out of 4 stars
Share This Review

Janet and Lynn West have just turned 13. They are two ordinary girls living in the foothills of the Blue Ridge Mountains. The rambunctious twins have a happy childhood until an ill-fated Saturday in June 2001. When their mother returns to pick them up after a day at the beach, they are nowhere to be seen. Suspecting foul play, the desperate parents notify the authorities. Despite the search teams and an extensive investigation, all efforts are in vain. What is worse, within a span of only ten years two more girls go missing from locations along the same road, US74A. In 2011, Special Agent Sean Tzu, an Abduction and Hostage Specialist, is assigned the case of the mysterious disappearances. As a father of a 13-year-old daughter called Kiera, Agent Tzu understands the parents’ despair and is determined to find out the truth.

Judgment At Hickory Nut Gorge by Dan Hedgepath is book one in the Sean Tzu mystery series. It might appeal to readers of hard-boiled thrillers full of terror, brutality, and murder. In fact, this is the only reason I am giving this novel 2 out of 4 stars instead of the lowest rating. Otherwise, the book did not come up to my initial expectations. On the contrary, it was rather disappointing in terms of both the plot and character development.

I have always been an avid reader of murder mysteries, so I thought the investigation of the girls’ disappearances would be just up my alley. Unfortunately, the book did not focus on the investigation proper. The story starts somehow promising with the description of the picturesque mountain resort area of Hickory Nut Gorge and the bizarre disappearance of the West twins. However, from that moment onwards, the plot development becomes disjointed and highly implausible. In a surreal quest for one sensational event after another, the author forgets about realism and credibility. From physical aggression and sexual abuse to brutal murder, arson, tragic car accidents, and even a plane hijacking, nothing escapes the author’s craving for more and more shocking scenes.

The book has only 240 pages in the PDF version. Regardless, I had to make extra efforts to remain focused throughout the ten chapters. Some of the scenes of child molestation were very hard to read, while some others, like Sarah’s motorbike accident or James Nesbitt’s death, are still haunting me with their lurid and macabre details. The main narrative thread is often inadequately interrupted by divergent threads that would be better removed. The fact that the perspective changes from a third-person focus on Judge Roy Norwood to Agent Tzu’s first-person point of view adds even more confusion in the readers’ minds.

The characters did not impress me much either. Both the investigator and the sexual predator have moments when their actions come out of the blue and do not fit into the general framework of the storyline. The only characters I could possibly relate to and pity were the poor young victims and their families.

All things considered, I would have given this novel only 1 star. I settled down for 2 stars thinking that there could still be readers out there who do not shy away from violent scenes or offensive language. After all, the book has a backbone narrative structure and some characters that stand out from the crowd. A good editor would probably make wonders about both the content and editing of this novel. There are numerous punctuation and grammar mistakes that could be eliminated with a solid round of proofreading and editing. A skilled editor could also help the author get rid of the unrealistic scenes and make the protagonists more believable. As it is, the book was far from what I am looking for in an exciting murder mystery.

Judgment At Hickory Nut Gorge
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
"The madness of writing is the antidote to true madness." (Hanif Kureishi)

User avatar
Posts: 222
Joined: 18 Aug 2019, 11:39
2019 Reading Goal: 25
2019 Reading Goal Completion: 316
Favorite Author: Jess Lederman
Favorite Book: David Copperfield
Currently Reading: Relentless
Bookshelf Size: 175
Reviewer Page:
Latest Review: Island Games by Caleb J. Boyer
fav_author_id: 164792

Post by LauraLeeWasHere »

I knew from the very first one of your reviews I read that you were not only an avid reader but a born reviewer. When I saw you had reviewed this book, I came to check it out. It sounds like it was a very difficult book to read and took some sacrifices on your part, but just think of how many people you spared from reading disturbing things without any forewarning. I am one of those people and so I wanted to express my gratitude for you "sticking it out".

Even your constructive and positive nature came through as you gave suggestions as to how this book could be improved and made sure to emphasize that it did have redeeming qualities.

Thanks again for your common sense, professionalism and dedication to doing your job so well.

Sincerely, Laura-Lee
And there are also many other things which Jesus did, if they should be written every one, I suppose that even the world itself could not contain the books that should be written. John 21:25 KJV

User avatar
Sarah Tariq
Posts: 1968
Joined: 17 Mar 2017, 02:17
2019 Reading Goal: 25
2019 Reading Goal Completion: 60
2018 Reading Goal: 25
2018 Reading Goal Completion: 96
2017 Reading Goal: 15
2017 Reading Goal Completion: 46
Currently Reading:
Bookshelf Size: 198
Reviewer Page:
Latest Review: One Way or Another by Mary J. Williams
Reading Device: PDF

Post by Sarah Tariq »

Though I rarely opt for mystery books, It's bad to see the poor character development and lackluster plot. Thanks for this honest review!
Make your ideals high enough to inspire you and low enough to encourage you.


User avatar
Bookshelves Moderator
Posts: 644
Joined: 17 May 2019, 01:15
2019 Reading Goal: 20
2019 Reading Goal Completion: 40
Favorite Author: Roger Glasgow
Favorite Book: Mythic Worlds and the One You Can Believe In
Currently Reading:
Bookshelf Size: 113
Reviewer Page:
Latest Review: Adrift by Charlie Sheldon
fav_author_id: 187887

Post by Julius_ »

I like thriller books, so, unlike you, I'm sure I'll love it! Thanks for the review. It was an awesome read!
We're all philosophers. When there's a tough choice to be made, when faced with the facts of birth,love or death or simply when thinking about what we want to do with our lives.

Post Reply

Return to “Crime, Thrillers, Mystery and Horror Books”