Review of The Elf Revelation
8 posts
[Following is an official OnlineBookClub.org review of "The Elf Revelation" by Jordan David.]
[I]The Elf Revelation[/I] by Jordan David is book nine in the [I]Magi Charter[/I] series. The series focuses on Santa and the elves and their mission, which has evolved over the years. This last chapter once again takes place in space. Santa has failed the mission, and the elves are spread throughout the galaxy. Their base is no longer functional. They must find a way forward. How will they continue their calling? What will they do without Santa's leadership?
Once again, I appreciate the new worlds and civilizations the author created. Also, it is interesting that he includes a whole section that pretty much mimics Shakespeare's Julius Caesar. He includes his own version of one of Shakespeare's most famous lines on page 438. “And you Brutios? Then fall Sonath …” Additionally, he has rearranged the story of Jesus' birth for his needs, complete with Christmas carol lyrics. All evidence of the author's great creativity.
I also appreciated the glossary the author included. All the previous Santas are listed. Any major character or species that you may have forgotten, you can look up, which is helpful.
Having said that, this book felt disappointing. I feel like the author has departed from the original intentions of the series. The first seven books are heavily focused on Santa and the elves. The eighth book does somewhat. This book departs from that and focuses more on the galaxy as a whole.
Also, the book is longer than it needs to be because he kept backing up and retelling the same event two, three, or four times from different perspectives. A very old battle is recounted in the book that doesn't seem to add to the story. At over 1300 pages, the book would be better if it were trimmed.
This book, as the last in the series, is meant to wrap up everything. However, the ending didn't feel satisfying enough to me. I did enjoy aspects of it, but I wanted more. It was a good ending to the book, but it wasn't a good ending to the series.
Lastly, the book is plagued with the same types of errors that plagued the other books in the series. Mostly, it's just careless typos that were never taken care of. For example, carrying is used instead of caring. Askes is written when it should be asks.
I have greatly enjoyed the series as a whole and would recommend it to anyone who loves a good story. I know Jordan David is a talented author. However, this book was disappointing. For the reasons I've listed, I rate[I]The Elf Revelation[/I] 3 out of 5 stars. It was enjoyable enough. Still, it was too long, didn't wrap up the series well enough, and had too many errors to warrant a higher rating.
******
The Elf Revelation
View: on Bookshelves
Once again, I appreciate the new worlds and civilizations the author created. Also, it is interesting that he includes a whole section that pretty much mimics Shakespeare's Julius Caesar. He includes his own version of one of Shakespeare's most famous lines on page 438. “And you Brutios? Then fall Sonath …” Additionally, he has rearranged the story of Jesus' birth for his needs, complete with Christmas carol lyrics. All evidence of the author's great creativity.
I also appreciated the glossary the author included. All the previous Santas are listed. Any major character or species that you may have forgotten, you can look up, which is helpful.
Having said that, this book felt disappointing. I feel like the author has departed from the original intentions of the series. The first seven books are heavily focused on Santa and the elves. The eighth book does somewhat. This book departs from that and focuses more on the galaxy as a whole.
Also, the book is longer than it needs to be because he kept backing up and retelling the same event two, three, or four times from different perspectives. A very old battle is recounted in the book that doesn't seem to add to the story. At over 1300 pages, the book would be better if it were trimmed.
This book, as the last in the series, is meant to wrap up everything. However, the ending didn't feel satisfying enough to me. I did enjoy aspects of it, but I wanted more. It was a good ending to the book, but it wasn't a good ending to the series.
Lastly, the book is plagued with the same types of errors that plagued the other books in the series. Mostly, it's just careless typos that were never taken care of. For example, carrying is used instead of caring. Askes is written when it should be asks.
I have greatly enjoyed the series as a whole and would recommend it to anyone who loves a good story. I know Jordan David is a talented author. However, this book was disappointing. For the reasons I've listed, I rate
******
The Elf Revelation
View: on Bookshelves
You are not logged in. Please log in or sign up to view members replies, participate in the discussion, and access more features.
