Review of All Writers Are Liars

Postby Becca Olsson »

[Following is an official OnlineBookClub.org review of "All Writers Are Liars" by Nicholas Bruechle.]
Book Cover
5 out of 5 stars
Share This Review


All Writers Are Liars written by Nicholas Bruechle, is an interesting tale about Baker McCloud, an author. The story begins with McCloud’s most recent work, his best work to date, being rejected from a writing contest. To prove his writing skills, McCloud endeavors to write a new greatest work. That’ll show them. This great work will be about Malcolm, an author. Malcolm’s life is falling apart following the death of his mother. To pull himself out of despair, he sits down to write a new type of book, his greatest work yet. This book comes to be about Murray, an author. Murray attempts a literary hoax on the publishing world, which will be his greatest work yet. I suggest you read this book to follow McCloud’s, Malcolm’s, and Murray’s works to find out if these literary works will be the best ones yet.

It was quite a feat attempting to summarize this book. There are layers upon layers, and they are not easy to explain. Despite this potential confusion, I believe Bruechle (the real-life author) succeeded in their storytelling. There are many positive aspects of this book of books. First and foremost, it’s an interesting look into the world of authors and publishing. Bruechle did a good job capturing the idea that all authors (at least within this book) feel their book will change the literary world, while also being unreliable narrators. Each layer of authors provides an interesting viewpoint on their experiences within the writing and publishing world.

The characters are all well-developed and well-rounded. All are given backstories and characteristics that are unique to each one, and the interactions between characters feel authentic and natural. Despite the repetitive ideas of each author attempting to write their greatest work, the book itself does not feel repetitive because each “author” writes in a different style. This is made more interesting when we remember that only one real-life author wrote each character author.

In my opinion, there are no negative aspects of this book. I found minimal typos. They were not enough to detract from the enjoyment of the book, and I believe the book was professionally edited. Due to the overwhelming positive aspects discussed above, I rate this book five out of five stars.

There is a lot of profanity and depictions of sexual assault and rape. Therefore, I would recommend this book for mature readers only who are looking for a compelling story that addresses one main question across multiple tiers: Can we trust writers at all?

******
All Writers Are Liars
View: on Bookshelves