Review of Secrets of the Kashmir Valley

Francis Kapola · Post by **Francis Kapola** » 19 May 2023, 01:27

[Following is a volunteer review of "Secrets of the Kashmir Valley" by Farhana Qazi.]

5 out of 5 stars

Share This Review

The Kashmiri youth, feeling oppressed, join demonstrations against Indian forces, resulting in violent clashes and deaths, with some labeled as wanted terrorists. Fearing for their safety, men, and women in the fight against the Indian police hide while unsympathetic police search their homes. Mothers cling to hope for their sons' and daughters’ return, only to discover their lifeless bodies. As the people demonstrate, they are arrested and taken to prison without a proper trial. While in prison, they suffer torture as they are made to accept that they are involved in terrorist activities. However, their strong resilience and willpower to see Kashmir live in freedom are the sources of strength that make them endure such torture.

In response, women rise against injustices, driven by their unique motivations. The author draws a contrast to women in early Islam, who protected themselves through battles, while Kashmiri women resort to violence to attract global attention to their plight. The violence in Kashmir does not end with beatings by the police; it continues to cause suffering, even to innocents. Women, who are vulnerable, are sexually abused by, who knows, the Kashmiri militia or the Indian police.

Through Mughli's story, the author skillfully portrays the intense emotions experienced by Kashmiris. Burhan Wani serves as an example of unwavering loyalty, sacrificing his privileged life to fight for Kashmir's freedom.

Farhana Qazi, even though she is a Muslim, presents an impartial view of Islam's jihad, firmly rejecting the notion of jihad as a path to God through violent actions such as suicide bombing and defining it as the pursuit of goodness over evil.

Thought-provoking questions posed by the author engage readers on a deeper level. Without significant drawbacks and the positive remarks stated above, the book deserves a rating of five out of five stars. However, the book contained a few minor errors that had no effect on the reading quality of the book.

Farhana's endorsement emphasizes the book's relevance to those interested in Kashmir, including human rights activists, scholars, writers, peacebuilders, and policymakers. The Secrets of the Kashmir Valley offers valuable insights into the ongoing turmoil faced by Kashmir's residents.

******
Secrets of the Kashmir Valley
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon

Post by **Hazel Mae Bagarinao** » 29 May 2023, 05:52

The title intrigues me. And the history of the Kashmir Valley seems a lot of life was wasted. It sounds like the historic events in the past were full of sadness. Your review is amazing, Francis!

Francis Kapola · Post by **Francis Kapola** » 19 Jun 2023, 04:51

Hazel Mae Bagarinao wrote: ↑29 May 2023, 05:52 The title intrigues me. And the history of the Kashmir Valley seems a lot of life was wasted. It sounds like the historic events in the past were full of sadness. Your review is amazing, Francis!

Thank you for your kind words! I'm glad you found the review amazing, and I hope the book provides you with a deeper understanding of the complexities and emotions surrounding the region's history.

Radical94 · Post by **Radical94** » 19 Jun 2023, 04:58

"If you want to gain a deeper understanding of Kashmir, I highly recommend reading this book. It delves into the lives of ordinary people who are caught in the midst of the dirty politics played out between two countries. It offers a poignant perspective on the challenges faced by individuals striving to lead happy lives in a region plagued by conflict and tension.

Through the author's engaging storytelling, the book sheds light on the human side of the Kashmir issue. It explores the aspirations, dreams, and struggles of the local population, giving voice to their experiences in a way that resonates with readers.

By delving into the complexities of the political situation, the book offers valuable insights into the consequences that ordinary people endure due to the actions of those in power. It emphasizes the universal desire for peace, stability, and the pursuit of happiness, which often get overshadowed by political agendas.

The narrative draws readers into the vividly portrayed landscape of Kashmir, immersing them in its culture, traditions, and the daily challenges faced by its inhabitants. It highlights the resilience and strength of the human spirit, even in the face of adversity.

This book serves as a powerful reminder that behind the headlines and geopolitical conflicts, there are individuals striving to create a better life for themselves and their families. It humanizes the Kashmir issue and encourages empathy and understanding among its readers.