OnlineBookClub.org

Hook is my all time fave and I adored Peter Pan (2003) starring Jeremy Sumpter. If anything, the Disney version is pretty good. Not my favorite and a little racist, but nice to watch.

Personally I love the original Disney (as has already been mentioned, it is racist at parts by today's standards), as well as Hook (a sequel: Peter left Neverland, became an adult with wife and children, until his children are kidnapped by Hook!).

Also, I do love how JM Barrie gave the rights for all future Pan films/books, so funds still go to Great Ormond Street Children's Hospital.

Hook is an all-time favorite of mine that I still enjoy!

The cast and the creative world that they fabricated are so much fun.

Definitely the Peter Pan (2003) one! Or maybe I'm biased because I had a crush on him when I was younger. If you haven't watched it yet, I recommend you to give it a try. I must have re-watched it a hundred times already.

Hook was pretty good too. It was fun to see Peter Pan as a adult and how he reacted when he went back to Neverland.

There's been a lot of Peter Pan remakes recently. But I don't think any of them can compare to the two mentioned above (Again, this is just my opinion!)

my favorite is both "Pan" and "Hook"

Hook is also my favorite.

Not sure if it counts, being a story about the story, but Finding Neverland was the best Peter Pan for me.

As far as movies go I really enjoyed the 2004 version of Peter Pan with Jeremy Sumpter ^w^
It didn't have completely everything like the books but it's flying song is used in most of the Disney commercials for their vacations now too! lol Also "Hook" is always a classic, I love the concept of "After Neverland" if Peter had decided to leave Neverland to grow up... its a cool idea!

rusalka wrote: ↑04 Mar 2018, 15:19 For me, nothing can beat the Disney movie. It manages to keep things light hearted, as opposed to the original Peter Pan book.

I agree! I loved the cartoon! I also watched one that was a stage production and the lead was played by a female. I was also very young and liked it. I probably wouldn't like it today.

Mailis wrote: ↑10 Feb 2018, 08:27 I have read now Peter Pan books to my kid, last one was Peter Pan in Scarlet and I think he would enjoy a Peter Pan movie as well. Which one is your favorite adaption of the lot?

Return to Neverland. Its simply the best adaptation

My opinion is that I think I'm fine with all adaptations. It's hard for me to decide what's best with things like this sometimes, and I guess I just don't mind, as long as it's good.

The most recent films are terrible: the last good film was 2003's Peter Pan. As far as animated films go, Walt Disney's Peter Pan (1953) is undoubtedly the best. The 1924 black-and-white Peter Pan is extraordinary with real actors, and the Spielberg-directed Hook is also great.