Forum Navigation: Forum Index » Books and Reading » General Book & Reading Discussion

Want FREE books and FREE Amazon gift cards?

Each day we announce via email a book that is either FREE or on a temporary sale at a great discount price. These are not your average free books. These are incredible insider deals on well-rated books. is where tomorrow's bestsellers are born. We also give away over $1,000 per month of free Amazon gift cards in free daily giveaways, exclusively to those signed up to these announcements! Hurry, sign up free now:

Sorry, this proves you are human.

How do YOU rate books when reviewing? Your personal thoughts

Use this forum for book and reading discussion that doesn't fall into another category. Talk about books, genres, reading issues, general literature, and any other topic of particular interest to readers. If you want to start a thread about a specific book or a specific series, please do that in the section below this one.

Re: How do YOU rate books when reviewing? Your personal thou

Post Number:#61 by Zoe303
» 30 Oct 2015, 13:59

A 4-star book has to be perfect, in my own standards of course. A 1-star book is one I really hated or considered a waste of time. My system of rating is quite weird I would say. A book would lose or gain a star depending on its lack of what I love in books or the presence of something I hate. For example, I don't like books with a lot of obscenities, so if it was one it would lose a star. And I love books with suspense, so if it had that it would get a star, and so on.
“Always read something that will make you look good if you die in the middle of it.” –P.J. O’Rourke
User avatar
Posts: 432
Joined: 17 Apr 2015, 15:15
Location: Biblioland
Currently Reading:
Bookshelf Size: 147 books
2017 Reading Goal: 45 Books
Goal Completion: 0%

Did you know?
Once you join the forums and log in you will get to enjoy a very ad-reduced experience. It's easy and completely free!

Re: How do YOU rate books when reviewing? Your personal thou

Post Number:#62 by MarieMc
» 01 Nov 2015, 15:32

I generally give up on a book If I have to rate it a 1. Why torture myself and the author? I think there should be a 5 as well for 'life changing, excellent'. I read a lot of books that I might give a 4 to, because they are really good, but I wouldn't say are life changing. These really good books I kind of hate to say are a 3 because 3 doesn't seem to be an all that good of a rating. It is certainly a dilemma.
Today is a good day
to have GOOD day!!
User avatar
Posts: 110
Joined: 08 Oct 2014, 19:38
Currently Reading: Host
Bookshelf Size: 40 books

View Reviewer Page
Reading Device: Kindle Paperwhite
2017 Reading Goal: 60 Books
Goal Completion: 1%

Re: How do YOU rate books when reviewing? Your personal thou

Post Number:#63 by Patientguy247
» 01 Nov 2015, 16:29

I feel that a book review should have 1 to 5 stars with 5 being the life changing review and a 4 being excellent. 3 should be so so. 2 should be not great but maybe others may think otherwise and 1 being horrible. Maybe i am wrong but that makes more sense to me in terms of rating a book.
User avatar
Posts: 5
Joined: 01 Nov 2015, 16:04
Bookshelf Size: 0 books

View Reviewer Page
2017 Reading Goal: 0 Books
Goal Completion: 0%

Re: How do YOU rate books when reviewing? Your personal thou

Post Number:#64 by MatthewAlexander
» 06 Apr 2016, 16:59

I understand what you mean...I personally have never given out a four, though I have given ones. When I give a book a one it's usually for a mixture of reasons, not just one specific flaw. For example, many of the ones I've given have been to books that were difficult to read due to the writing style or the technical errors; some books simply should have been given more work before being published. Fours are definitely harder to come by; I'd have to be very touched and blown away by a book to give it a four.
MatthewAlexander's Latest Review: "Jump" by Michel Sauret
User avatar
Posts: 230
Joined: 23 Apr 2014, 15:59
Currently Reading: It's Kind of a Funny Story
Bookshelf Size: 21 books

View Reviewer Page
2017 Reading Goal: 10 Books
Goal Completion: 0%

Re: How do YOU rate books when reviewing? Your personal thou

Post Number:#65 by Scerakor
» 20 Mar 2017, 18:40

Wow, this sure has harboured a lot of interesting discussions. I agree with a lot of what has said w.r.t. the awkwardness of the 4 star rating system, but here is another stick to throw in the spokes. I find that, especially for what we are doing here, the 4 star system actually works out a bit better than a 5 star or other (i.e. letter grade) system the way that it is defined in the guidelines. It removes a bit of ambiguity.

1 = bad, 2 = fair, 3 = good, 4 = excellent); basically if you give it a 3 or a 4 you are recommending others read it, if you give a 1 you are strongly recommended other people do not bother reading it, and if you give it a 2 that's sort of ambiguous since obviously you didn't like it that much but maybe others will.

For me then, 1 means DO NOT READ, 2 means I didn't like it (or it wasn't great) but still has merit, 3 means I liked it, and 4 means I really liked it.

The issues with perfection being unattainable so a four is never given is less an issue to me if we look at it this way. 4 simply means it is a very good book and is well edited. 1 means I wouldn't recommend it at all. 2 and 3 are equally simple. The more letters/numbers/smiley faces we put in a rating system, the less likely we would be to give the top and bottom marks.

My $.02
Scerakor's Latest Review: "Tag" by John Collings
User avatar
Posts: 321
Joined: 13 May 2013, 13:43
Currently Reading: The Long Utopia
Bookshelf Size: 34 books

View Reviewer Page
2017 Reading Goal: 52 Books
Goal Completion: 50%

Re: How do YOU rate books when reviewing? Your personal thou

Post Number:#66 by Dh_
» 24 Mar 2017, 15:45

I think I review books in a sinilar way. I never give the book a one unless it was absolutely horrible and I could not finish reading it. Most of them are twos and threes for me too. A book only gets a 4 if it was very well written and kept me interested the whole time or if the concept and plot are something completely original and intriguing. It might be a little harsh, but you're not the only one that does it.
Dh_'s Latest Review: "Solstice" by Braxton A Cosby
User avatar
Posts: 179
Joined: 28 Nov 2016, 17:15
Location: Florida, USA
Favorite Author: Alex Flinn
Favorite Book: Carry On
Currently Reading: Crystal Storm
Bookshelf Size: 109 books

View Reviewer Page
2017 Reading Goal: 50 Books
Goal Completion: 26%

Re: How do YOU rate books when reviewing? Your personal thou

Post Number:#67 by Amagine
» 24 Mar 2017, 16:53

I realized that there is no book that deserves 4 stars. I don't think I would ever give a 4 star rating because every book that I reviewed had a fatal flaw that kept it from getting 4 stars from me.
There's no such thing as a kid who hates reading. There are kids who love reading, and kids who are reading the wrong books."-James Patterson
User avatar
Posts: 3006
Joined: 04 Mar 2017, 19:27
Location: Lost in My Imagination
Favorite Author: James Patterson
Favorite Book: Writing for Children and Teens
Currently Reading: Heavy Sketches - Volume II
Bookshelf Size: 611 books

View Reviewer Page
Reading Device: Fire HD 7 Tablet
2017 Reading Goal: 400 Books
Goal Completion: 37%


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Whitten39 and 3 guests


Return Home » Books and Reading » General Book & Reading Discussion